All great stories begin with a dream

… and someone who believes in it!

The History of St. Andrew’s By-The-Sea UMC

The history of St. Andrew’s by-the-Sea United Methodist Church began with a few special people who had a vision of a church by the sea for a people called Methodists. The combination of an enthusiastic Dr. Ken Miller, a District Superintendent who wanted to start new churches, and a thoughtful Bishop, Gerald Kennedy, proved to be an excellent combination for the start of St. Andrew’s. While on vacation Bishop Kennedy met Dr. & Mrs. Ray Reeves who lived in San Clemente. When Bishop Kennedy shared his hopes of starting a church in their city, the Reeves decided to give the land to the Methodist church and the seeds of present-day St. Andrew’s had been planted. 

Bishop Kennedy tapped a young pastor from Mississippi named Maxie Dunham and on Easter Sunday, March 29, 1964, the first formal worship service of St. Andrew’s, was held at the San Clemente Elks Club. On December 20, 1964, the fledgling church broke ground on their new property and ten months later, on October 17, 1965, the first service was held in the new church on Calle Frontera. 

St. Andrew’s held worship services in that space until the early 1990s when the current Sanctuary building was completed. Today, the Sanctuary building is used for worship services, weddings, memorials, and occasional concerts. The ground floor also houses Children’s Programs and the Nursery. The original church building, named the Fellowship Hall today, is home to our offices, the Youth program, as well as a shared space with San Clemente Military Family Outreach. 

Memorial Garden

In 2005, St. Andrew’s added the Memorial Garden which is administered by the St. Andrew’s Foundation. The Memorial Garden is one of the only columbariums in south Orange County. 

We have had several pastors in our 60+ year history and are delighted to have Rev. Karl Stuckenberg as our lead pastor since 2021. We’ve come a long way since our first worship service at the Elks Lodge in March 1964! But what has not changed is our desire to Connect, Grow, and Serve – both in our local community and more broadly.